Media proposal scorecard

Compare up to three media supplier proposals on audience fit, delivery, cost, measurement and practical requirements.

How to use the workbook

  1. Set the weights before you score

    Adjust the six criteria to suit the brief. For an audience-led buy, weight audience fit more heavily. Use a total of 100 across the criteria.

  2. Compare on the same basis

    Use the same campaign dates, geography and cost basis. Ask suppliers how they calculated audience estimates and which charges sit outside the media rate.

  3. Record the evidence

    Rate each proposal from 1 to 5, then note the evidence and any follow-up questions. Use the weighted score to prompt a decision discussion with the team.

Common questions

What should I compare beyond the headline price?

Compare fees, creative costs, cancellation terms, makegoods, added value and what each supplier can report. Confirm which costs are included before comparing totals.

Explore media buying support
How is each supplier’s score calculated?

The workbook weights each 1–5 rating by its criterion. It calculates a score out of 100 once all six ratings are complete and the weights add to 100.

Get the media planning toolkit