What should I compare before signing off a media plan?
Give each supplier the same outcome, audience, geography, dates and budget basis. Ask for the cost to run the media and the total cost to deliver the campaign. Then compare how much of your audience each plan can reach, what it can measure and who owns the work after you approve it.
Before opening the quotes, decide which requirements could rule out a proposal. For a supermarket launch, that might mean confirmed availability in the regions being targeted. For enquiries, it might mean a working conversion event and a clear way to judge lead quality.
Four checks to run on every proposal
Ask each supplier to answer on the same basis so you can see where the plans actually differ.
- Audience and geography
Ask how the target audience is defined, whose data supports it and which regions are covered. Compare reach and frequency within the target group wherever the estimates allow it.
- Costs and commitments
Ask for working media, management fees, ad serving or data charges, production and GST on separate lines. Confirm cancellation terms and how missed delivery would be handled.
- Forecast and assumptions
Ask what the forecast assumes about dates, inventory, targeting and creative. Record the assumptions that would change the recommendation if they turn out to be wrong.
- Measurement and ownership
Agree the source of truth, reporting window and primary outcome. Name who checks the tracking before launch and who can reallocate spend during the campaign.
Compare what the same $18,000 buys
Illustrative figures in NZD excluding GST. All-in CPM includes the full proposal cost per 1,000 forecast impressions.
Working media
Forecast impressions
All-in CPM
Worked example: two $18,000 proposals
Illustrative figures in NZD excluding GST. The objective is to reach shoppers in three launch regions. One option buys a broad network package. The other proposes more specific placements in those regions.
| What to compare | Proposal A · broad network | Proposal B · regional placements |
|---|---|---|
| Total cost | $18,000 | $18,000 |
| Working media | $16,000 | $14,000 |
| Forecast impressions | 1,000,000 | 700,000 |
| All-in cost per 1,000 forecast impressions | $18.00 | $25.71 |
| What to ask next | How many impressions and unique people are in the three launch regions? | What reach and frequency can you substantiate for the same regions and audience? |
How I’d make the decision
Proposal A forecasts more impressions for the same total cost. I'd ask both suppliers to show estimated target reach and frequency across the three launch regions before choosing. If Proposal B can show it makes better use of those regions, there may be a case for paying more per impression.
Record the decision and its assumptions in the scorecard. At review, compare what ran against what was promised and use the same definition of audience and outcome wherever the data supports it.